OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions: a scoping review to identify candidate instruments

Florian Naye; Karine Toupin-April; Maarten de Wit; Annie LeBlanc; Olivia Dubois; Annelies Boonen; Jennifer L Barton; Liana Fraenkel; Linda C Li; Dawn Stacey; Lyn March; Claire E H Barber; Glen Stewart Hazlewood; Francis Guillemin; Susan J Bartlett; Dorthe B Berthelsen; Kate Mather; Laurent Arnaud; Akpabio Akpabio; Adewale Adebajo; Grayson Schultz; Victor S Sloan; Tiffany K Gill; Saurab Sharma; Marieke Scholte-Voshaar; Francesco Caso; Elena Nikiphorou; Samah Ismail Nasef; Willemina Campbell; Alexa Meara; Robin Christensen; Maria E Suarez-Almazor; Janet Elizabeth Jull; Rieke Alten; Esi M Morgan; Yasser El-Miedany; Jasvinder A Singh; Jennifer Burt; Arundathi Jayatilleke; Ihsane Hmamouchi; Francisco J Blanco; Anthony P Fernandez; Sarah Mackie; Allyson Jones; Vibeke Strand; Sara Monti; Simon R Stones; Rebecca R Lee; Sabrina Mai Nielsen; Vicki Evans; Hemalatha Srinivasalu; Thomas Gérard; Juliette LeBlanc Demers; Roxanne Bouchard; Théo Stefan; Michèle Dugas; Frédéric Bergeron; Dorcas Beaton; Lara J Maxwell; Peter Tugwell; Simon Décary

OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions: a scoping review to identify candidate instruments

Florian Naye, Karine Toupin-April, Maarten de Wit, Annie LeBlanc, Olivia Dubois, Annelies Boonen, Jennifer L Barton, Liana Fraenkel, Linda C Li, Dawn Stacey, Lyn March, Claire E H Barber, Glen Stewart Hazlewood, Francis Guillemin, Susan J Bartlett, Dorthe B Berthelsen, Kate Mather, Laurent Arnaud, Akpabio Akpabio, Adewale AdebajoGrayson Schultz, Victor S Sloan, Tiffany K Gill, Saurab Sharma, Marieke Scholte-Voshaar, Francesco Caso, Elena Nikiphorou, Samah Ismail Nasef, Willemina Campbell, Alexa Meara, Robin Christensen, Maria E Suarez-Almazor, Janet Elizabeth Jull, Rieke Alten, Esi M Morgan, Yasser El-Miedany, Jasvinder A Singh, Jennifer Burt, Arundathi Jayatilleke, Ihsane Hmamouchi, Francisco J Blanco, Anthony P Fernandez, Sarah Mackie, Allyson Jones, Vibeke Strand, Sara Monti, Simon R Stones, Rebecca R Lee, Sabrina Mai Nielsen, Vicki Evans, Hemalatha Srinivasalu, Thomas Gérard, Juliette LeBlanc Demers, Roxanne Bouchard, Théo Stefan, Michèle Dugas, Frédéric Bergeron, Dorcas Beaton, Lara J Maxwell, Peter Tugwell, Simon Décary

The Parker Institute

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: Shared decision making (SDM) is a central tenet in rheumatic and musculoskeletal care. The lack of standardization regarding SDM instruments and outcomes in clinical trials threatens the comparative effectiveness of interventions. The Outcome Measures in Rheumatology (OMERACT) SDM Working Group is developing a Core Outcome Set for trials of SDM interventions in rheumatology and musculoskeletal health. The working group reached consensus on a Core Outcome Domain Set in 2020. The next step is to develop a Core Outcome Measurement Set through the OMERACT Filter 2.2.

METHODS: We conducted a scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) to identify candidate instruments for the OMERACT Filter 2.2 We systematically reviewed five databases (Ovid MEDLINE®, Embase, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and Web of Science). An information specialist designed search strategies to identify all measurement instruments used in SDM studies in adults or children living with rheumatic or musculoskeletal diseases or their important others. Paired reviewers independently screened titles, abstracts, and full text articles. We extracted characteristics of all candidate instruments (e.g., measured construct, measurement properties). We classified candidate instruments and summarized evidence gaps with an adapted version of the Summary of Measurement Properties (SOMP) table.

RESULTS: We found 14,464 citations, read 239 full text articles, and included 99 eligible studies. We identified 220 potential candidate instruments. The five most used measurement instruments were the Decisional Conflict Scale (traditional and low literacy versions) (n=38), the Hip/Knee-Decision Quality Instrument (n=20), the Decision Regret Scale (n=9), the Preparation for Decision Making Scale (n=8), and the CollaboRATE (n=8). Only 44 candidate instruments (20%) had any measurement properties reported by the included studies. Of these instruments, only 57% matched with at least one of the 7-criteria adapted SOMP table.

CONCLUSION: We identified 220 candidate instruments used in the SDM literature amongst people with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases. Our classification of instruments showed evidence gaps and inconsistent reporting of measurement properties. The next steps for the OMERACT SDM Working Group are to match candidate instruments with Core Domains, assess feasibility and review validation studies of measurement instruments in rheumatic diseases or other conditions. Development and validation of new instruments may be required for some Core Domains.

Original language	English
Article number	152344
Journal	Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism
Volume	65
Pages (from-to)	152344
ISSN	0049-0172
Publication status	Published - Apr 2024

Keywords

Adult
Child
Humans
Decision Making, Shared
Rheumatic Diseases/therapy
Rheumatology
Outcome Assessment, Health Care
Consensus

Cite this

Naye, F., Toupin-April, K., de Wit, M., LeBlanc, A., Dubois, O., Boonen, A., Barton, J. L., Fraenkel, L., Li, L. C., Stacey, D., March, L., Barber, C. E. H., Hazlewood, G. S., Guillemin, F., Bartlett, S. J., Berthelsen, D. B., Mather, K., Arnaud, L., Akpabio, A., ... Décary, S. (2024). OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions: a scoping review to identify candidate instruments. Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism, 65, 152344. Article 152344.

Naye, F, Toupin-April, K, de Wit, M, LeBlanc, A, Dubois, O, Boonen, A, Barton, JL, Fraenkel, L, Li, LC, Stacey, D, March, L, Barber, CEH, Hazlewood, GS, Guillemin, F, Bartlett, SJ, Berthelsen, DB, Mather, K, Arnaud, L, Akpabio, A, Adebajo, A, Schultz, G, Sloan, VS, Gill, TK, Sharma, S, Scholte-Voshaar, M, Caso, F, Nikiphorou, E, Nasef, SI, Campbell, W, Meara, A, Christensen, R, Suarez-Almazor, ME, Jull, JE, Alten, R, Morgan, EM, El-Miedany, Y, Singh, JA, Burt, J, Jayatilleke, A, Hmamouchi, I, Blanco, FJ, Fernandez, AP, Mackie, S, Jones, A, Strand, V, Monti, S, Stones, SR, Lee, RR, Nielsen, SM, Evans, V, Srinivasalu, H, Gérard, T, Demers, JL, Bouchard, R, Stefan, T, Dugas, M, Bergeron, F, Beaton, D, Maxwell, LJ, Tugwell, P & Décary, S 2024, 'OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions: a scoping review to identify candidate instruments', Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism, vol. 65, 152344, pp. 152344.

@article{bb264f5a6c8c4815a91c1c00dabae1d8,

title = "OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions: a scoping review to identify candidate instruments",

abstract = "OBJECTIVES: Shared decision making (SDM) is a central tenet in rheumatic and musculoskeletal care. The lack of standardization regarding SDM instruments and outcomes in clinical trials threatens the comparative effectiveness of interventions. The Outcome Measures in Rheumatology (OMERACT) SDM Working Group is developing a Core Outcome Set for trials of SDM interventions in rheumatology and musculoskeletal health. The working group reached consensus on a Core Outcome Domain Set in 2020. The next step is to develop a Core Outcome Measurement Set through the OMERACT Filter 2.2.METHODS: We conducted a scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) to identify candidate instruments for the OMERACT Filter 2.2 We systematically reviewed five databases (Ovid MEDLINE{\textregistered}, Embase, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and Web of Science). An information specialist designed search strategies to identify all measurement instruments used in SDM studies in adults or children living with rheumatic or musculoskeletal diseases or their important others. Paired reviewers independently screened titles, abstracts, and full text articles. We extracted characteristics of all candidate instruments (e.g., measured construct, measurement properties). We classified candidate instruments and summarized evidence gaps with an adapted version of the Summary of Measurement Properties (SOMP) table.RESULTS: We found 14,464 citations, read 239 full text articles, and included 99 eligible studies. We identified 220 potential candidate instruments. The five most used measurement instruments were the Decisional Conflict Scale (traditional and low literacy versions) (n=38), the Hip/Knee-Decision Quality Instrument (n=20), the Decision Regret Scale (n=9), the Preparation for Decision Making Scale (n=8), and the CollaboRATE (n=8). Only 44 candidate instruments (20%) had any measurement properties reported by the included studies. Of these instruments, only 57% matched with at least one of the 7-criteria adapted SOMP table.CONCLUSION: We identified 220 candidate instruments used in the SDM literature amongst people with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases. Our classification of instruments showed evidence gaps and inconsistent reporting of measurement properties. The next steps for the OMERACT SDM Working Group are to match candidate instruments with Core Domains, assess feasibility and review validation studies of measurement instruments in rheumatic diseases or other conditions. Development and validation of new instruments may be required for some Core Domains.",

keywords = "Adult, Child, Humans, Decision Making, Shared, Rheumatic Diseases/therapy, Rheumatology, Outcome Assessment, Health Care, Consensus",

author = "Florian Naye and Karine Toupin-April and {de Wit}, Maarten and Annie LeBlanc and Olivia Dubois and Annelies Boonen and Barton, {Jennifer L} and Liana Fraenkel and Li, {Linda C} and Dawn Stacey and Lyn March and Barber, {Claire E H} and Hazlewood, {Glen Stewart} and Francis Guillemin and Bartlett, {Susan J} and Berthelsen, {Dorthe B} and Kate Mather and Laurent Arnaud and Akpabio Akpabio and Adewale Adebajo and Grayson Schultz and Sloan, {Victor S} and Gill, {Tiffany K} and Saurab Sharma and Marieke Scholte-Voshaar and Francesco Caso and Elena Nikiphorou and Nasef, {Samah Ismail} and Willemina Campbell and Alexa Meara and Robin Christensen and Suarez-Almazor, {Maria E} and Jull, {Janet Elizabeth} and Rieke Alten and Morgan, {Esi M} and Yasser El-Miedany and Singh, {Jasvinder A} and Jennifer Burt and Arundathi Jayatilleke and Ihsane Hmamouchi and Blanco, {Francisco J} and Fernandez, {Anthony P} and Sarah Mackie and Allyson Jones and Vibeke Strand and Sara Monti and Stones, {Simon R} and Lee, {Rebecca R} and Nielsen, {Sabrina Mai} and Vicki Evans and Hemalatha Srinivasalu and Thomas G{\'e}rard and Demers, {Juliette LeBlanc} and Roxanne Bouchard and Th{\'e}o Stefan and Mich{\`e}le Dugas and Fr{\'e}d{\'e}ric Bergeron and Dorcas Beaton and Maxwell, {Lara J} and Peter Tugwell and Simon D{\'e}cary",

year = "2024",

month = apr,

language = "English",

volume = "65",

pages = "152344",

journal = "Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism",

issn = "0049-0172",

publisher = "W.B./Saunders Co",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions

T2 - a scoping review to identify candidate instruments

AU - Naye, Florian

AU - Toupin-April, Karine

AU - de Wit, Maarten

AU - LeBlanc, Annie

AU - Dubois, Olivia

AU - Boonen, Annelies

AU - Barton, Jennifer L

AU - Fraenkel, Liana

AU - Li, Linda C

AU - Stacey, Dawn

AU - March, Lyn

AU - Barber, Claire E H

AU - Hazlewood, Glen Stewart

AU - Guillemin, Francis

AU - Bartlett, Susan J

AU - Berthelsen, Dorthe B

AU - Mather, Kate

AU - Arnaud, Laurent

AU - Akpabio, Akpabio

AU - Adebajo, Adewale

AU - Schultz, Grayson

AU - Sloan, Victor S

AU - Gill, Tiffany K

AU - Sharma, Saurab

AU - Scholte-Voshaar, Marieke

AU - Caso, Francesco

AU - Nikiphorou, Elena

AU - Nasef, Samah Ismail

AU - Campbell, Willemina

AU - Meara, Alexa

AU - Christensen, Robin

AU - Suarez-Almazor, Maria E

AU - Jull, Janet Elizabeth

AU - Alten, Rieke

AU - Morgan, Esi M

AU - El-Miedany, Yasser

AU - Singh, Jasvinder A

AU - Burt, Jennifer

AU - Jayatilleke, Arundathi

AU - Hmamouchi, Ihsane

AU - Blanco, Francisco J

AU - Fernandez, Anthony P

AU - Mackie, Sarah

AU - Jones, Allyson

AU - Strand, Vibeke

AU - Monti, Sara

AU - Stones, Simon R

AU - Lee, Rebecca R

AU - Nielsen, Sabrina Mai

AU - Evans, Vicki

AU - Srinivasalu, Hemalatha

AU - Gérard, Thomas

AU - Demers, Juliette LeBlanc

AU - Bouchard, Roxanne

AU - Stefan, Théo

AU - Dugas, Michèle

AU - Bergeron, Frédéric

AU - Beaton, Dorcas

AU - Maxwell, Lara J

AU - Tugwell, Peter

AU - Décary, Simon

PY - 2024/4

Y1 - 2024/4

N2 - OBJECTIVES: Shared decision making (SDM) is a central tenet in rheumatic and musculoskeletal care. The lack of standardization regarding SDM instruments and outcomes in clinical trials threatens the comparative effectiveness of interventions. The Outcome Measures in Rheumatology (OMERACT) SDM Working Group is developing a Core Outcome Set for trials of SDM interventions in rheumatology and musculoskeletal health. The working group reached consensus on a Core Outcome Domain Set in 2020. The next step is to develop a Core Outcome Measurement Set through the OMERACT Filter 2.2.METHODS: We conducted a scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) to identify candidate instruments for the OMERACT Filter 2.2 We systematically reviewed five databases (Ovid MEDLINE®, Embase, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and Web of Science). An information specialist designed search strategies to identify all measurement instruments used in SDM studies in adults or children living with rheumatic or musculoskeletal diseases or their important others. Paired reviewers independently screened titles, abstracts, and full text articles. We extracted characteristics of all candidate instruments (e.g., measured construct, measurement properties). We classified candidate instruments and summarized evidence gaps with an adapted version of the Summary of Measurement Properties (SOMP) table.RESULTS: We found 14,464 citations, read 239 full text articles, and included 99 eligible studies. We identified 220 potential candidate instruments. The five most used measurement instruments were the Decisional Conflict Scale (traditional and low literacy versions) (n=38), the Hip/Knee-Decision Quality Instrument (n=20), the Decision Regret Scale (n=9), the Preparation for Decision Making Scale (n=8), and the CollaboRATE (n=8). Only 44 candidate instruments (20%) had any measurement properties reported by the included studies. Of these instruments, only 57% matched with at least one of the 7-criteria adapted SOMP table.CONCLUSION: We identified 220 candidate instruments used in the SDM literature amongst people with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases. Our classification of instruments showed evidence gaps and inconsistent reporting of measurement properties. The next steps for the OMERACT SDM Working Group are to match candidate instruments with Core Domains, assess feasibility and review validation studies of measurement instruments in rheumatic diseases or other conditions. Development and validation of new instruments may be required for some Core Domains.

AB - OBJECTIVES: Shared decision making (SDM) is a central tenet in rheumatic and musculoskeletal care. The lack of standardization regarding SDM instruments and outcomes in clinical trials threatens the comparative effectiveness of interventions. The Outcome Measures in Rheumatology (OMERACT) SDM Working Group is developing a Core Outcome Set for trials of SDM interventions in rheumatology and musculoskeletal health. The working group reached consensus on a Core Outcome Domain Set in 2020. The next step is to develop a Core Outcome Measurement Set through the OMERACT Filter 2.2.METHODS: We conducted a scoping review (PRISMA-ScR) to identify candidate instruments for the OMERACT Filter 2.2 We systematically reviewed five databases (Ovid MEDLINE®, Embase, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and Web of Science). An information specialist designed search strategies to identify all measurement instruments used in SDM studies in adults or children living with rheumatic or musculoskeletal diseases or their important others. Paired reviewers independently screened titles, abstracts, and full text articles. We extracted characteristics of all candidate instruments (e.g., measured construct, measurement properties). We classified candidate instruments and summarized evidence gaps with an adapted version of the Summary of Measurement Properties (SOMP) table.RESULTS: We found 14,464 citations, read 239 full text articles, and included 99 eligible studies. We identified 220 potential candidate instruments. The five most used measurement instruments were the Decisional Conflict Scale (traditional and low literacy versions) (n=38), the Hip/Knee-Decision Quality Instrument (n=20), the Decision Regret Scale (n=9), the Preparation for Decision Making Scale (n=8), and the CollaboRATE (n=8). Only 44 candidate instruments (20%) had any measurement properties reported by the included studies. Of these instruments, only 57% matched with at least one of the 7-criteria adapted SOMP table.CONCLUSION: We identified 220 candidate instruments used in the SDM literature amongst people with rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases. Our classification of instruments showed evidence gaps and inconsistent reporting of measurement properties. The next steps for the OMERACT SDM Working Group are to match candidate instruments with Core Domains, assess feasibility and review validation studies of measurement instruments in rheumatic diseases or other conditions. Development and validation of new instruments may be required for some Core Domains.

KW - Adult

KW - Child

KW - Humans

KW - Decision Making, Shared

KW - Rheumatic Diseases/therapy

KW - Rheumatology

KW - Outcome Assessment, Health Care

KW - Consensus

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85182679800&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Review

C2 - 38232625

SN - 0049-0172

VL - 65

SP - 152344

JO - Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism

JF - Seminars in Arthritis and Rheumatism

M1 - 152344

ER -

OMERACT Core outcome measurement set for shared decision making in rheumatic and musculoskeletal conditions: a scoping review to identify candidate instruments

Abstract

Keywords

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this