Multimodality detection of tumour rupture in children with Wilms tumour

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Tumour rupture (TR) signifies stage III disease and requires treatment intensification, which includes radiotherapy. We studied the associations between radiological, surgical and pathology TR in children with Wilms tumour (WT) in a United Kingdom multicentre clinical study.

PATIENTS AND METHODS: The IMPORT (Improving Population Outcomes for Renal Tumours of Childhood) study registered 712 patients between 2012 and 2021. Children with TR on central radiology review (CRR) at diagnosis and/or indication of preoperative TR on surgical forms were included. Correlation between radiology/surgery/pathology findings was made.

RESULTS: Total 141 patients had TR identified (69 on CRR, 43 on surgical form and 29 on both), and 124/141 had images available for CRR, and 98/124 had features suggestive of TR on diagnostic CRR (63 magnetic resonance imaging/35 computed tomography). TR was limited to the renal fossa in 47/98 (48%) and intraperitoneal in 51/98 (52%). Three of 98(3%) had upfront surgery, and 87/95 (92%) had TR confirmed on post-chemotherapy preoperative scans. Among 80/98 (82%) cases with TR on CRR and available surgical forms, TR was not confirmed on surgery or pathology in 38/80, giving a false-positive rate of 48%. Preoperative TR was indicated on 72 surgical forms, with images available for CRR in 55. Twenty-six of 55 (47%) were false-negative for TR on CRR and of those 10/26 (38%) had TR confirmed on pathology.

CONCLUSIONS: Radiology alone should not be used to define TR, as it does not accurately correlate with surgical or pathology findings, and therefore cannot be relied upon for definitive staging and treatment. A multidisciplinary team should take the decision regarding the final abdominal stage and treatment using a multimodality approach considering clinical, radiological, surgical and pathological findings.