TY - JOUR
T1 - Setting a research agenda for the use of extended reality in healthcare simulation
T2 - an Utstein style meeting
AU - Issenberg, Barry
AU - Ostergaard, Doris
AU - Matos, Francisco
AU - Ingrassia, Pier Luigi
AU - Freeman, Kirsty
AU - Konge, Lars
AU - Sa-Couto, Carla
AU - Reedy, Gabriel
AU - Ricci, Serena
AU - Crawford, Scott
AU - Barbar, Samia
AU - Dieckmann, Peter
AU - Dow, Olivia
AU - Younsi, Myriam Alami
AU - Vadla, May Sissel
AU - Lazarovici, Marc
AU - Aksoy, M. Emin
AU - Huang, Lennox
AU - Brown, Kristen
AU - Estila, Joana Berger
AU - Acharya, Asmita
AU - The Utstein XR in Simulation Expert Group
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2026.
PY - 2026/3/3
Y1 - 2026/3/3
N2 - Background: Extended reality (XR), encompassing virtual, augmented, and mixed reality, is increasingly integrated into healthcare simulation-based education and training. While XR offers immersive, scalable, and potentially cost-effective learning environments, evidence of its educational effectiveness and implementation remains fragmented. To address this gap, an Utstein-style consensus meeting was convened to establish an international research agenda that advances the evidence-based integration of XR in healthcare education. Methods: The meeting, held in Copenhagen, Denmark, in November 2024, brought together 24 international experts representing diverse disciplines, geographic regions, and simulation expertise. A Delphi-informed pre-meeting survey, based on a targeted review of XR-focused literature, identified key topics across five initial domains. Using an implementation science–informed approach guided by the NASSS (Non-adoption, Abandonment, Scale-up, Spread, and Sustainability) framework, participants engaged in structured breakout and plenary discussions to explore barriers, facilitators, and research priorities related to XR adoption and sustainability. Results: Through consensus deliberation, the original five domains were refined into three overarching themes: (1) uses and adoption of XR, (2) barriers to XR adoption and implementation, and (3) facilitators of XR implementation and sustainability. Each theme comprised multiple subthemes addressing critical issues such as technological definitions, economic and infrastructure needs, human resource and faculty development, usability, educational quality, customization, and ethical considerations. Research questions within each subtheme were classified as descriptive, justificatory, or clarificatory to guide future study design and methodological rigor. Conclusions: This Utstein Style meeting represents the first international, consensus-based effort to develop a structured research agenda for XR in healthcare simulation. Informed by implementation science, particularly the NASSS framework, the resulting agenda provides a roadmap for future research, policy, and practice. It emphasizes faculty readiness, institutional investment, and data-driven evaluation as prerequisites for sustainable integration. By addressing barriers and leveraging facilitators, the healthcare simulation community can advance the responsible adoption of XR technologies, enhancing competency, equity, and innovation in health professions education worldwide.
AB - Background: Extended reality (XR), encompassing virtual, augmented, and mixed reality, is increasingly integrated into healthcare simulation-based education and training. While XR offers immersive, scalable, and potentially cost-effective learning environments, evidence of its educational effectiveness and implementation remains fragmented. To address this gap, an Utstein-style consensus meeting was convened to establish an international research agenda that advances the evidence-based integration of XR in healthcare education. Methods: The meeting, held in Copenhagen, Denmark, in November 2024, brought together 24 international experts representing diverse disciplines, geographic regions, and simulation expertise. A Delphi-informed pre-meeting survey, based on a targeted review of XR-focused literature, identified key topics across five initial domains. Using an implementation science–informed approach guided by the NASSS (Non-adoption, Abandonment, Scale-up, Spread, and Sustainability) framework, participants engaged in structured breakout and plenary discussions to explore barriers, facilitators, and research priorities related to XR adoption and sustainability. Results: Through consensus deliberation, the original five domains were refined into three overarching themes: (1) uses and adoption of XR, (2) barriers to XR adoption and implementation, and (3) facilitators of XR implementation and sustainability. Each theme comprised multiple subthemes addressing critical issues such as technological definitions, economic and infrastructure needs, human resource and faculty development, usability, educational quality, customization, and ethical considerations. Research questions within each subtheme were classified as descriptive, justificatory, or clarificatory to guide future study design and methodological rigor. Conclusions: This Utstein Style meeting represents the first international, consensus-based effort to develop a structured research agenda for XR in healthcare simulation. Informed by implementation science, particularly the NASSS framework, the resulting agenda provides a roadmap for future research, policy, and practice. It emphasizes faculty readiness, institutional investment, and data-driven evaluation as prerequisites for sustainable integration. By addressing barriers and leveraging facilitators, the healthcare simulation community can advance the responsible adoption of XR technologies, enhancing competency, equity, and innovation in health professions education worldwide.
KW - Augmented Reality (AR)
KW - Extended Reality (XR)
KW - Healthcare simulation
KW - Mixed Reality (MR)
KW - Research agenda
KW - Simulation-based education
KW - Utstein style meeting
KW - Virtual Reality (VR)
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105031961856
U2 - 10.1186/s41077-026-00409-y
DO - 10.1186/s41077-026-00409-y
M3 - Journal article
C2 - 41776623
AN - SCOPUS:105031961856
SN - 2059-0628
VL - 11
JO - Advances in Simulation
JF - Advances in Simulation
IS - 1
M1 - 16
ER -