Identification of risk products for fragrance contact allergy: a case-referent study based on patients' histories

BACKGROUND: Fragrances are the first or second most common cause of contact allergy in dermatitis patients.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify risk products for fragrance contact allergy.

METHODS: The design was a case-control study with a case group of 78 fragrance-mix-positive eczema patients and two control groups, one consisting of 1,279 subjects selected as a random sample of the general population and the other consisting of 806 fragrance-mix-negative eczema patients. The identification of risk products was based on the patients' histories of rash to scented products. Analysis of the associations between first-time rash caused by different specified product categories and fragrance mix sensitivity was performed using logistic regression.

RESULTS: It was found that first-time rash caused by deodorant sprays and/or perfumes were related to fragrance contact allergy in a comparison with both control groups. The risk (odds ratio) of being diagnosed as fragrance allergic was 2.3 to 2.9 greater in cases of a history of first-time rash to deodorant sprays and 3.3 to 3.4 greater in cases of a history of rash to perfumes than if no such history were present. First-time rash to cleansing agents, deodorant sticks, or hand lotions was also statistically significant but only in comparison with one of the control groups.

CONCLUSION: Safety evaluation of fragrance materials used in perfumes and deodorant sprays should be performed with special attention.